Smart Home, Dumb Human
Or: Why My Light Switch Now Needs a Software Update
We used to joke that we’d never understand our kids. These days, I’m not sure I understand my house.
A while ago, I dipped a toe into the “smart home” world. It started innocently enough — a smart plug to control a lamp behind the TV. One command, and boom, the living room glowed like I actually knew what I was doing. I was a man in control. I even gave it a fancy name: TV Light.
Feeling confident, I added a second smart plug in my office. It turned on the desk lamp — until one day it didn’t. It blinked, sighed (digitally), and told me it needed to be reset. Just like that, my office light had become emotionally unavailable. Now I have a small collection of smart plugs sitting quietly on the credenza behind me, waiting for a firmware redemption arc.
The Alexa Situation
We do have Alexa in three rooms. And I’ll give credit where it’s due: she plays music on demand fairly consistently. She’s gotten better over time, even when I throw her a curveball like “Play Dave Brubeck… no, the live one… no, the other live one.” Occasionally she’ll launch into something wildly unrelated, but hey — who among us hasn’t confused Brubeck with Beyoncé?
Still, I have the nagging suspicion she’s listening a little too well. Like when I casually mention needing a new garden hose, and by dinner, my phone is showing me “Top 10 Ultra-Reliable Expandable Hose Deals.”
Coincidence? Alexa says yes. I say, hmm.
The Cautious Expansion Plan
We’ve talked about upgrading to smart appliances. You know, ovens that talk to your fridge, which talks to your phone, which probably talks to some cloud server in Iceland. Sounds neat in theory — until you realize the dishwasher and refrigerator might start conspiring about your sodium intake.
We’ve also looked at smart locks and cameras. But do we really need a door that texts me when someone knocks? Especially when that someone is the UPS driver who never rings the bell anyway.
There’s always the Ring doorbell, which seems like the gateway drug of smart home tech. But beyond that? You start eyeing real costs, and suddenly you’re in capital expenditure territory — where a door lock costs more than your first used car and the only ROI is a 3-second video of your neighbor’s cat.
-
- Smart Toaster
Knows your bread preference, tracks usage trends, and suggests artisanal loaves on Instagram.
→ “I just want it to stop burning the English muffins.”
- Smart Toaster
The Troubleshooting Olympics
Smart homes come with their own version of the decathlon — where each “event” involves resetting something. Smart plugs need resets. Apps stop syncing. The Wi-Fi goes out, and suddenly the lights don’t know whether they’re supposed to be on, off, or blinking like a nightclub.
But if you want the gold medal in household frustration, just try using a Smart TV.
We have two — both decent models — and we stream using YouTube TV, which works… most of the time. But navigating them means dealing with the so-called smart remotes, which seem convinced they know what I want.
I press “Guide,” and it gives me a random collection of recommendations I’ve never asked for — including shows in languages I don’t speak and sports I didn’t know existed. I hit “Back,” and it takes me to an entirely different app.
Sometimes the remote gets confused and switches inputs just to see if I’m paying attention.
And now, of course, the remote is on my phone — because what the phone really needed was another job. Apparently, I’m supposed to control the TV, my lights, the coffee pot, the front door, and check my heart rate — all from the same device I used to just make phone calls.
It’s not a smartphone anymore. It’s a nervous breakdown in my pocket.
Tech-Savvy… in Theory
I’m not opposed to technology. I’ve run technology based businesses, coded in more than one language, and survived a few operating systems that should’ve been taken out back and retired early. But smart homes are a different beast — they pretend to help, but they require you to learn their way of thinking.
And heaven help you if two devices try to talk at once. I once asked for the weather and got the jazz station. Then when I asked for music, it gave me a five-day forecast in Spanish.
- Smart Oven
Can preheat from your phone. Also occasionally updates in the middle of dinner.
→ “Dinner will be delayed. The oven is installing security patches.”
The Value Question
Like a lot of our friends, we’ve hit the wall of “how smart is smart enough?” Sure, locking your doors from the car sounds cool. But when did we become too tired to use a key?
The equation isn’t just about convenience anymore — it’s about value. Does the refrigerator really need to tell me when I’m out of eggs? Can the oven just cook dinner without needing a Wi-Fi password? And do I really want a smart shower that refuses to warm up until I’ve completed a mindfulness check-in?
Final Thought
Smart homes are seductive. They promise convenience, safety, even savings. But more often than not, they deliver confusion, troubleshooting, and voice assistants that just need a nap.
Probably could add in something about Smart TVs (we have two but use YouTube TV rather than Roku or such) and add in the so call smart remotes that think they know what you want until you override them and getting the remote on the phone is just one more thing that a phone should not be doing.
I’m not giving up on the tech. But for now, Alexa plays the jazz, a couple of lights respond (most of the time), and I’m keeping the rest of the smart plugs in time-out until they prove they’re emotionally stable.
If my house is going to be smarter than me, the least it can do is help me find my Kindle.
- Smart Oven
Can preheat from your phone. Also occasionally updates in the middle of dinner.
→ “Dinner will be delayed. The oven is installing security patches.”
